Investment Research & Governance · MCH Publications

Performance & Backtesting Policy

How MCH classifies performance outputs and the disclosures that accompany backtests, simulations and forecasts.

Effective date
Last updated
Version
1.1
Operator
MCH Advisory (Pty) Ltd

This policy governs how MCH Publications classifies and discloses performance information: model returns, simulation portfolios, historical alpha, backtests, portfolio comparisons, return forecasts and options scenario payoffs. It forms part of the MCH Publications policy framework and is one of the research-governance standards, alongside the Research Integrity Policy.

01

Scope

This policy applies to every page and publication that shows:

  • model returns
  • simulation portfolios
  • historical alpha
  • backtests
  • portfolio comparisons
  • return forecasts
  • options scenario payoffs
02

Required classifications

Every performance output should be classified as one of:

  • actual/live
  • audited actual
  • hypothetical
  • simulated
  • backtested
  • paper
  • forecast/expected

Different classifications must not be merged into one apparent historical-performance series without clear disclosure.

03

Backtest disclosures

Backtests are hypothetical unless explicitly identified otherwise. Where relevant, a backtest should disclose its assumptions, including:

  • starting universe
  • delisting treatment
  • survivorship controls
  • data availability
  • point-in-time treatment
  • rebalance date
  • transaction costs
  • slippage
  • liquidity assumptions
  • taxes
  • dividends
  • corporate actions
  • execution assumptions
  • leverage
  • shorting costs
  • options pricing assumptions
04

Expected returns

Expected returns, target prices and probability-weighted outcomes must be described as estimates, not as realised performance.

05

Historical returns

Historical model or simulation results must not be labelled in a manner that suggests they are returns actually earned by clients or by MCH, unless that is demonstrably true.

06

Charts

Every performance chart should carry a concise classification label near the chart, not only in a distant footer. Examples:

  • BACKTEST — hypothetical, not actual investment performance
  • SIMULATED PORTFOLIO — transaction costs and other assumptions apply
Related policies

Questions about this policy: research@mchadvisoryservices.com. All policies: MCH Publications legal.